Almost nothing in
Lennettes childhood prepared her for a paycheck kind of job.
When she was born two days after the Fourth of July in 1966, her father named her,
loosely, for Mouseketeer Annette Funicello. It did not confer on her a Disney life.
For years, Lennettes family lived in a 100-year-old log cabin on 17 acres owned
by her fathers family. It had no running water and no indoor plumbing. Lennette and
her older brother and sister carried water to the house from springs. They split wood to
burn in the stove that heated the cabin. Their father, Wendell Nicholson, taught them to
farm there.
The family received welfare payments because Nicholson was an alcoholic who
couldnt hold jobs for long. He beat all his children and sexually abused the girls.
Lennettes mother, Betty, knew about the sexual abuse but could not protect the
children.
The incest ended only after Lennette and her brother ran away and told a relative, who
called the police. Nicholson pleaded guilty and served two years in prison. The two older
children went to foster care, but Lennette, who was 12, remained with her mother. Betty
forced the girl to visit her father in prison and allowed Wendell to return after
hed served his time.
Things were never good after that. Lennettes brother was in and out of reform
schools and, ultimately, was imprisoned for burglary. Her sister left to live with a woman
who ran a personal-care home. And Lennette kept skipping school and running away.
Thats how she met Clair.
One fall day, a few months after Lennette turned 16, she told her mother a fib about
where she was going. She said she planned to spend the night with friends in a trailer
just past the last coal patch house in Melcroft.
A patch is a group of houses slapped together by coal companies so their workers could
live near portals or strip sites. About 80 patches remain in Fayette County. This one sits
between the Frank Lloyd Wright house, Fallingwater, and Seven Springs, a ski resort that
attracts cars that are worth more than the coal patch homes.
Instead of going to the trailer that night, Lennette went to a house in the middle of
the patch to baby-sit for several days. She figured shed earn some money and have a
good excuse for cutting school.
The family who employed her didnt mention that theyd taken in a 20-year-old
neighborhood man, Clair Kistner. He showed up at the house in the middle of the night,
drunk and fresh from a fistfight.
"I was scared to death of him. It took me three days to talk to him. Everybody
said I should have known then," Lennette says. But she didnt.
Eventually, she talked to him, then dated him.
They had much in common, and maybe thats what drew them to each other. Neither
liked, valued or finished school, although Clair made it through the 10th grade in
special-education classes. Both had grown up in poverty without decent father figures.
Clairs father left before he was born. Like Lennettes mother, Clairs
depended on welfare to support the family. When Clair was 16, his mother dumped him and
two siblings on an uncle in Melcroft because her new boyfriend didnt want them.
Four years later, Clair and the uncle argued about Clairs drinking, and Clair
ended up at the neighbors house. He thought Lennette was cute and pursued her.
They decided to marry a few months later. They dressed up to go to the courthouse to
exchange vows before a judge, but they were turned away because they didnt have the
required blood tests for a marriage license. A few days later, after theyd taken the
tests, they rode to the county seat in the back of a pickup truck, both in blue jeans. It
was Feb. 25, 1983.
Marrying emancipated Lennette, so she could sign herself out of school, something her
mother had refused to do.
The decision to quit school has come to haunt her. Today, she has trouble understanding
legal or technical documents, like the letters from the welfare office ordering her to
show up for meetings on the new rules requiring work. And she still has trouble taking
tests, such as her drivers license exam. She tried nine times to get a permit and
never passed the written test, which means she lives in the middle of nowhere 24
miles from a supermarket, 30 miles from the doctor who treats her lupus and
cant drive.
When Lennette quit school, it turned out that she had traded her pencils and books for
something equally daunting bottles and dirty diapers. She was several weeks
pregnant when she wed. She found out when she and Clair took the marriage license blood
tests.