
Making
Oakland a good place
for walkers
Lose the wrong way bus lane
With acknowledgment to Mao Tse-tung (among many others), a journey of a thousand miles
is said to begin with a single step.
And the single step that is essential to begin the thousand mile journey of improving
Oakland is the elimination entirely of the perverse contraflow bus lane on Fifth Avenue.
Without taking this initial single step, Oakland will never cease to be the creepy,
edgy, eerie, odd, uncomfortable, unbalanced, deviant (i.e., unintegrated with the larger
community which surrounds it) district which it is today, dominated externally by a
totally unnecessary but very real and statistically proven danger.
Currently, nobody can plan to go or to be directed to Oakland without being cautioned
-- "You better look out for those buses going the wrong way on the Main Street in
Oakland."
With the elimination of the contra-flow (i.e. contrary-flow) bus lane, parents in the
fall will once again be able to say farewell to their daughters and sons beginning a new
year at one of the universities with the words, "See you at Thanksgiving,"
instead of, "Watch out for the buses."
Marvin L. Bellin, Squirrel Hill
A needed
crossing light
A serious problem in Oakland is the dangerous intersection of Bigelow Boulevard and
Forbes Avenue, smack in the middle of the "campus," between the Cathedral of
Learning and the William Pitt Union on the one side and Hillman Library & Forbes Quad
(now Posvar Hall) on the other. Why on earth are there no "Walk/Dont Walk"
signs at this intersection, as every other one in the vicinity (at Bigelow and Fifth, at
Bellefield and Forbes, etc.)?
Traffic is very heavy, with cars turning in various directions and numerous outbound
buses loading at the corner. Many students and faculty members have to dash across this
intersection between classes, dodging turning vehicles. Video equipment is trundled across
on rollers. Handicapped persons make the perilous crossing in wheelchairs.
The congestion at this hazardous intersection was one reason people wanted to close the
block of Bigelow Boulevard between the Cathedral and the union, which I dont
advocate. It is a public thoroughfare. Yet for some unknown reason this critical
intersection is not equipped with routine safety signals. Jaywalkers on Bigelow almost
feel justified in taking their chances at midblock because the intersection at Forbes
Avenue is just as dangerous.
Making this improvement would help far more than university students -- it would
benefit one of the most vital areas of the city.
Jane Flanders, Squirrel Hill
Close Bigelow
between Fifth and Forbes
One of the most cost-effective changes with the most immediate return to improve the
Oakland section would be to revisit the issue of converting Bigelow Boulevard between
Fifth and Forbes [avenues] to a Pitt campus.
Lets face it, the Pitt students are one of the citys finest
"products," and spending a few bucks on their safety and convenience will have
far-reaching and lasting benefit to this community.
Frank B. Zeno, Pittsburgh
Pedestrian
bridge
My idea for improvement would be to build a pedestrian crossing bridge from the patio
of the second floor of the Cathedral of Learning, across Bigelow Boulevard, into the old
Schenley Hotel Building. This enclosed bridge could have stairs descending down to the
sidewalk. There should be stairs on both sides of the street.
Al Sperl, Mount Oliver
Pedestrian
bridge II
My idea on how to make an improvement in Oakland and in particular the University of
Pittsburgh is to build pedestrian bridges over city streets near the Cathedral of
Learning, which would give somewhat of a cohesive campus feeling to the university which
it now does not have.
Louis Ray Fefolt, Finleyville
Walkways/connectors
I would like to suggest that, with the addition of Pitts Convocation Center,
there should be more above-ground walkways, whether moving or stationary, that connect
various buildings and sites, such as the Scaife, Convocation Center, Dental School and
Tower View Parking Lot.
It is a difficult walk up the hills (physically), especially in the winter when it is
cold, gets dark very early and, therefore, is not very safe.
If some of the students, staff and faculty of the University and Health Center could
use such walkways, there would be less traffic congestion, fewer shuttle buses, and,
hopefully, reduced crime. I know someone who was assaulted for money on his way up a hill
one evening, and that was during the summer and during daylight.
Rose Gennari
Walkway and parking
1. When coming down South Craig Street to Forbes Avenue, give Craig a left-turn arrow
before traffic exiting the museum has a green light.
2. Add either an underground or overtraffic walkway to Bigelow Boulevard between the
Cathedral of Learning and the Pitt Student Union, because too many students do not use the
crosswalks provided. Or ticket the students that do not use crosswalks.
3. I think a good-size parking garage is needed. It may be intertwined with a few
stores or shops. A suggested place is between Hillman Library and the Carnegie Library.
There is a parking lot there now, but building upward would be advantageous to everyone.
Lack of parking has been a reason that many locals and visitors have given for not
visiting Oakland more. Another place [for more parking] may be where Pitts stadium
was.
4. Another thought for the space where the Pitt stadium was is a park to keep the track
part where employees walk or run at lunch time. It would be great to picnic there in the
summer time with your lunch. Theres not nearly enough greenery in that part of
Oakland.
Wendelyn Weckerle, Carnegie Museum of Art
Targeting
traffic
I believe the No. 1 issue facing Oakland is traffic congestion and that the following
changes will move both people and vehicles through the area more efficiently and
effectively:
Build one 16-foot-wide covered pedestrian walkway above Fifth Avenue that crosses the
street near the Litchfield Towers and another that crosses from the Pitt Student Union to
the Cathedral grounds. The clearance for both walkways should be low to prohibit large
trucks from using the roads between Forbes and Fifth avenues.
Eliminate the parking meters along Bigelow Boulevard between Forbes Avenue and
Bayard/OHara streets to open up the traffic lanes. There may be an option to widen
the green space along this section of Bigelow.
Take the corner off at Forbes Avenue and Bellefield Avenue to make left turns easier
and more efficient. This would require removing one tree.
Prohibit delivery trucks from double-parking to make deliveries on Forbes Avenue.
Instead, clearly mark and enforce specific loading zones at the corners of each major
intersection.
Paint all intersections with a grid to identify them clearly and prohibit vehicles from
entering and stopping in these zones at red lights. Enforce this law with heavy fines.
Currently, this system is used very effectively in New York City.
Take the corner off at Forbes Avenue and Halket to make the right-hand turn from Forbes
to Halket quicker and more efficient.
Make cuts in the sidewalks on the main streets where hospital and university shuttles
stop so they can load and unload passengers without blocking traffic.
Reconfigure the serpentine path that currently makes up University Drive when the new
convocation center is built.
Make better use of the old Syria Mosque space by building an underground parking lot
topped with green space that could be used as a small park.
Ultimately, build a subway system that would connect Oakland to Downtown and eventually
to the North Side and the East End to eliminate the need for commuters to transfer to and
from buses. This would eliminate the need for many of the buses that currently congest the
main streets.
As part of the Oakland subway system, build a loop that connects Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
and Carlow with the local hospitals to reduce the number of hospital and university
shuttles currently on the roads.
Yet another subway loop could connect Oakland with large parking garages located along
Second Avenue and Panther Hollow. This loop also could travel over to the new sports
medicine complex on the South Side. People would be more inclined to park on the edge of
Oakland if quick, inexpensive, convenient transportation to the heart of the area were
available.
Add another underground parking garage topped by green space between the Hillman and
Carnegie libraries.
The city empties public trash cans along Forbes Avenue during the business day. If
possible the cans should be emptied before 7 a.m. or after 8 p.m. to reduce the impact on
traffic flow.
Michael A. Tarquinio
A potpourri of thoughts
Here are my suggestions for Oakland improvements
Stop the chaos introduced every week by the so-called street sweeping. It is
ineffective and just causes the already congested parking situation to become untenable.
Absentee landlords exacerbate the run-down quality of too many properties.
Formulate an adaptive reuse program for the former Angels Corner church at Atwood
and Bates.
Encourage unique family businesses such as the Community Deli on Dawson Street, the
Italian Grocery Store on Bates, and Salems Market on Bouquet Street to continue
their services to the community by offering them tax incentives.
Restore and paint the rusted railings along the Boulevard of the Allies overpass over
Forbes Avenue. The railings have interesting ornamentation and could enhance that small,
but regularly traveled section of roadway. It also desperately needs to be resurfaced.
Adaptively reuse the building adjacent to this site.
Lu Donnelly, Point Breeze
Parking,
Bigelowand bus lane
I agree that Oakland and the University of Pittsburgh are assets to the city.
I think anything that can be done to improve parking, and make the campus look more
like a campus will pay dividends to the city for years to come.
I would begin by immediately closing Bigelow Boulevard between the Cathedral and the
student union. I know this is not a new idea.
I was taking an evening class during the experimental closure a few years ago. It was
very nice. I can only imagine how beautiful the whole area will look once the street has
been replaced with grass and trees.
I like the parking garage that was built under the lawn at Soldiers & Sailors
Memorial Hall. I thought for many years something similar should be done with the parking
lot in front of Hillman Library.
Building the garage below a park would help tie in the Pitt campus with CMU and
Schenley Park.
Something needs to be done with Fifth Avenue. Saying there is a lot of pedestrian
traffic in Oakland is an understatement.
I was an undergraduate the year the bus lane was added. Two-way traffic coupled with
the addition of a railing along the sidewalk make crossing the street dangerous.
Pedestrians cant be expected to cross only at a few traffic lights.
I realize it would be very costly, but I propose putting Fifth Avenue underground from
Bigelow to DeSoto , the street that leads to the stadium).
This approximately three block stretch separates the dormitories from most of the
campus.
Access to the Schenley Quad would need to be maintained.
A few extra parking spaces could be used as a loading zone for students at the
beginning and end of the school year.
I hope many good ideas are collected and that our local leaders act quickly on the
best.
Mark Marsico, McCandless
Buses direct to Oakland
One obvious way to make Oakland a better, especially more
accessible place is to have buses that go to Oakland without going Downtown! I live out
Route 8 way, and there is no direct connection for us out there without the long jog to
Downtown Pittsburgh, then change buses to get back to Oakland. I have never been able to
understand why this should be the case, since Oakland is clearly a major center for
people. Surely better transportation to the area would be a great (even though simple
minded) improvement!
Mary Dawson, Carnegie Museum
Make it
somewhere the young want to stay
Pittsburgh has four main assets: its educational institutions, health facilities,
sporting facilities and achievements, and its rivers. The citys greatest asset,
though, is its ability to attract people. It may not keep them, but it does an excellent
job getting them. I learned that from experience as Pitt tried to get me into their
graduate program -- and it did.
The focus has been, however, on the heavy emigration this region suffers.
On the other hand, the city continues to experience a reverse flow in the form of young
people who come here to be educated. The fact that they spend four years here is enough
time to get them hooked on the city and the region.
How do we do this? Transportation is crucial. This has always gone hand-in-hand with
spatial and economic expansion. As the number of students increases, moving them in a
timely way is important. The current system is beginning to show flaws along the 71A bus
route, the most traveled.
One student remarked that there are too many traffic lights on Fifth Avenue. The
problem is there is no way to bypass them.
A metro system can carry more people faster with no traffic lights, and its like
car pooling. This can operate at peak hours or increase the number of cars on the metro
system during peak hours. Amtrak did this during Thanksgiving and moved almost half a
million people in a few days.
Another critical element of keeping young people is entertainment. One of my first
shocks as a student here was how far I had to travel to get to the cinema. A modern cinema
or theater in Oakland is a must for the future.
Adequate and affordable housing is essential. Standards must be enforced in order to
halt the decadence and improve maintenance particularly in North and South Oakland.
Interuniversity athletic competitions among Pitt, Duquesne, Carnegie Mellon and Indiana
University of Pennsylvania can certainly add to the ambiance of the city and bring people
together. This would certainly do well to improve athletics in the area. Academic
performance gives a school its name; sports gives it its heart. It is athletic rivalry
that builds school spirit. It brings a city to life.
Ted D. Serrant, graduate student researcher
University Center for Social and Urban Research, University of Pittsburgh
|